Top Five: Peeple Isn’t for People — It’s for Recruiters

Scroll down to read more!

Top Five: Peeple Isn’t for People — It’s for Recruiters

Scroll down to read more!

Table of Contents

We like rating and quantifying things. Quick, give me your top five restaurants, your top five after work bars, and your top five dog parks! I bet you’ve got a partial list already. Now give me your top five bosses, exes, and neighbours! Does that feel a little strange? Rating the complex relationships you’ve developed with friends, neighbours, and colleagues?

The new in-development app Peeple invites you to do just that: rate everyone in your life as a series of quantifiables. How’s his hair? Like, maybe a 3 out of 5. Presentation skills? Solid 4, would hire again. Peeple founders Julia Cordray and Nicole McCullough pitch the app as Yelp for people and tout Yelp’s 79% positive reviews as proof that people are “fundamentally good.” (No mention of the fact that many Yelp reviewers are paid.) Peeple, they say, won’t be abused because the internet proves that people, when writing under their real names, are motivated to share positive things. Unfortunately, Facebook, Twitter, and workplace rating systems of the past have proven that people are glad to share loads of negative feelings too. Peeple will come with a host of features meant to precent abuse, but they seem unlikely to be effective. It takes an awful lot of effort to cultivate a positive community — it doesn’t happen all by itself.

The news generated hundreds of think pieces overnight, so I’ve pulled out five pieces that add — hopefully — new information or new ideas to the conversation:

Peeple is the ‘Yelp for People’ App Your Mother Warned You About

James Vincent breaks down the structural problems with the human ratings platform at the Verge: you can rate others without their consent and there are no provisions for dealing with subtly discriminatory reviews. Add to that the lack of discussion of how the founders will deal with harassment and defamation on their service.

Why the Philosophy of People-Rating App Peeple Is Fundamentally Flawed

The New Statesman argues that the core problem with Peeple is rating people assumes that character is fixed: that past behaviour is a good predictor for future behaviour; that people don’t change; and that public shaming is good and should continue indefinitely. People are not a service or a commodity. People are complex beings who have done good and bad in their lives.

People Bleater

So vague are descriptions of how Peeple will actually function that Snopes fact-checked the app, thinking it might be a hoax. Suspicious factors include the founders’ lack of background in app development, the absence of any mention of Peeple prior to the Washington Post interview, and the lack of any product specifications or technical updates. Their conclusion: Peeple may be real but it’s unlikely to make it to the app store in November.

Peeple Is for Employers, Not People

At Motherboard, Jordan Pearson points out that everything we know about Peeple suggests that it’s designed for recruiting. Not only do the founders have a background in recruiting, but the app itself works like a personal resume — its structure encourages you to participate on Peeple, police your reviews relentlessly, and secure good reviews from friends and colleagues. This is LinkedIn on steroids, but with a view into your private life.

The Problem with Rating People On the New App Peeple

Jospeh Reagle, assistant professor of Digital Communications at Northeastern says that Peeple will face yet another hurdle: “People are both ratingphilic and ratingphobic. The app takes advantage of the fact that people love to rate and peruse the ratings of others. But people are uneasy when the tables turn and the ratings are about them.” Peeple is another in a long line of startups that have tried to monetize the rating of people — and few have succeeded in their mission. If the ratings culture is too negative, people will flee. If it’s too positive, people will get bored and leave. What’s an app like Peeple to do?

Did you like this post? Share it!

One Comment

  1. Peeple is about 12 years behind in their application. Planet’s Choice is 17 years old and about to launch after failing in this market for the 4th time.

    November 20th 2016, The World’s First Public Praise and Recognition Company launches to help save Humanity from taking a “Nose Dive”.

    -Founder & Lead Archivist
    Planet’s Choice
    http://www.publicarchives.info

Comments are closed.

A Word From Our Sponsors

Ads help make Workology resources free for everyone. We respect your privacy. To see our Privacy Policy click here.

Recommended Posts

12 Types of Paid and Unpaid Leave and Time Off

A list for the HR professional to be able to answer employee questions related to time off....
Places to visit while in Chicago for the #SHRM13

Top 10 Must Sees in Chicago During #SHRM24

Must Sees in Chicago at the 2024 SHRM Annual Conference We’ve taken the stress out of planning and done all the work for you....

The Debate on Social Media Policies and Disclaimers The Debate on Social Media Policies and Disclaimers The Debate on Social Media Policies and Disclaimers The Debate On Social Media Policies and Disclaimers

5 Employee Twitter Bio Disclaimers You Should Add Today

Learn the top five Twitter (X) bio disclaimers every HR professional needs to protect personal and professional interests on social media....

How to Calculate FLSA Overtime Pay

Understand the Fair Labor Standards Act and learn how to calculate FLSA overtime pay to avoid any mistakes....
Discover the Best of Chicago

Top 10 Things to do in Chicago

Check out our free Yoga for HR class and take a break from #shrm24 at www.yogaforhr.com. Top 10 Things to do in Chicago Chicago...

Successful SHRM recertification

Your Path to Successful SHRM Recertification

Navigate your SHRM recertification journey with our guide. Uncover the process, benefits, and tips for successful career advancement in HR....

Navigating Career Change: Transitioning from HR to a New Career Path

Thinking about leaving HR for a new career? It happens to the best of us. Here's what you should consider first....

Going Paperless: Transitioning to a PDF-Based Workflow for Enhanced Efficiency

Going Paperless: Transitioning to a PDF-Based Workflow for Enhanced Efficiency Every day, we juggle deadlines, manage information overload, and constantly seek ways to streamline...

Checkout Our Products

Ads help make Workology resources free for everyone. We respect your privacy. To see our Privacy Policy click here.

More From Workology

Navigating Career Change: Transitioning from HR to a New Career Path

Thinking about leaving HR for a new career? It happens to the best of us. Here's what you should consider first.

5 Effective Employee Training Methods for 2024

Click on read more to open this post on our blog.

HR Certification Podcast Episode 15: Reviewing Employment Law for HRCI & SHRM Exams

In this episode of the HR Certification Podcast, we review employment law topics including adverse impact and the four-fifths rule.
Yoga for HR

Breathe Out Chaos, Breathe In Peace: Yoga for HR

Check out our free, 30-minute "Yoga for HR" webinar and learn how to clear your mind of chaos and clutter through breathwork and stretching!