Paid vs. Unpaid Internships: Why Top Companies are Happy to Pay
NathanParcells | Gen Y, HR, Millenials, Work| By
Internships: To Pay or Not to Pay
The conversation about paid vs unpaid internships is brought up constantly. Two of the most thoughtful posts on this subject were written by Ross Herosian at SiriusXM and Dave Olson at Hootsuite. Both Ross and Dave run fantastic internship programs, both are customers of ours at InternMatch, however, both support quality unpaid internships.
With some surveys reporting that upwards of 50% of total internships are unpaid, including those in both Congress and in the Senate, it is worth acknowledging the difference between high quality unpaid roles, which at times can be way better then low-quality paid internships, and the myriads of other unpaid positions that are fully exploitative, and in some cases are against US Employment laws specifically the FLSA. (read more here)
That being said, the reasons to pay interns far outweigh the rationale for not paying interns, and the savviest employers we speak to, large and small are getting ahead of the competition by growing their teams through paid internship programs. Below are the three biggest reasons we see successful companies happily paying their interns.
(As a side note, InternMatch has always paid our interns, even as a small, under-financed, 2-person startup, dating back to 2009. We have also always found higher value this way for many of the reasons below).
Most of the companies we speak to are interested in building a diverse workforce that brings new ideas, skills, and backgrounds to their company. Unfortunately, diverse students, particularly first generation US college students, are the ones hit the hardest by unpaid internship programs. In this way, unpaid positions are not just bad for students, forcing them to choose between valuable professional experience, and work that allows them to cover increasingly expensive college tuition, but also bad for employers who miss out on a massive and valuable segment of the college audience.
Interns are the future DNA of your company (and the #1 way in which employers make new grad hires) so the hiring makeup of an intern class often represents the makeup of a company as a whole.
I recently wrote a piece on the 500 Startups blog entitled What makes an Intern Hire Great including a slide stating that an exceptional intern can easily add 50K of value to your company, whereas an okay intern can easily subtract 25K in value. While interns are often hugely rewarding, the cost of a hiring a bad intern can be substantial, from becoming a management time suck, to creating office frustration. So, making the right intern hires is extremely important. By substantially narrowing your pool of potential hires with an unpaid internship program you dramatically increase the odds that the intern you hire will not be the right fit.
The good news is that you don’t need to pay interns a lot to be able to hire the best. We have found that paid positions on our site will see 4 to 5 times as many applicants, even if the payment amount is only minimum wage or $10/hour. So, when it comes to intern compensation, marginal pay increases often lead to massive talent increases.
Ultimately, the number one reason companies hire interns (over 83% as a matter of fact) is an effort to try and convert students to full-time hires. Over 70% of interns are offered full-time jobs, but not all take those jobs. It turns out that payment is one of the biggest determining factors of whether a student who is offered a full-time offer will accept.
CBS Interactive is a fantastic example of a company who has led the in terms of supporting strong intern compensation for all their interns. As a result, their student talent has gone up, and the number of hires they make through their internship programs pays substantial dividends to their company for years to come.
Removing the Ethics of Internship Compensation
Leaving out the substantial ethics and ethical argument for paid internships and internship compensation, companies who serious about college hiring are all hiring paid interns, because they care about the people they work with and want to hire the best.
Read more about the paid versus unpaid internship debate and how labor and employment laws might impact your decision as a manager on which you choose. Click here.
I’m a little skeptical … I think it depends on the company. I worked seven internships in college. Four of them were unpaid. Three were “paid.” But minimum wage only makes a minimal dent in your expenses … one paid only gas stipends … one paid $10/hour.
The internships I worked that were paid had much higher demands, full-time-job demands, in fact … of their interns. I know I only have my experience and no data, but my unpaid internships were far more valuable to me because they led me spread my wings a bit and it was more about learning, not doing intern-level-work.
I don’t know. Just a thought.
Nathan Parcells says
Thanks for the note and sharing your experiences. While I do agree that at certain times in a students’ life and as it seems it was the case for you, an unpaid role can often come with more flexibility, both in hours and oversight that can be helpful to a student exploring new professional opportunities.
That said, the overwhelming evidence shows that employers who hire for unpaid roles, because, of the unpaid nature, invest less in their intern program and are less likely to provide the kind of real world experience that is most valuable for students looking to tranisition into a full-time role.
This NACE survey shows that in the graduating class of 2012 60% of students who had paid internships received job offers while only 37% of those with unpaid internships received job offers which is just 1% higher than the number of students who had no internship experience at all.
For students who are looking to use an internship as a tool to gain relevant experience that increases their likelihood of landing a job after college, finding paid roles is incredibly important.
[…] The conversation about paid vs unpaid internships is brought up constantly. Two of the most thoughtful posts on this subject were written by Ross Herosian at SiriusXM and Dave Olson at Hootsuite. Both Ross and Dave run fantastic internship programs, both are customers of ours at InternMatch, however, both support quality unpaid internships…..read more. […]
[…] only does this company offer students a paid internship position, it also offers perks like one-on-one mentorship, business lunch chats, Q&As with the […]
[…] not receive any of these three components. A shared ethics on the subject of internships means a shared ethics for human resources in museum more generally. This type of shared ethics can only be a positive thing for both […]